April 01, 2004
So often, when I am at a loss to express what I want to say, Peggy Noonan steps in and does the job for me:
What they did in Fallujah, Iraq, on yesterday was such an event. The ambush, grenading, shooting and killing of four American civilians, the setting of their SUVs on fire and the brutalization of their corpses was savage, primitive, unacceptable. The terrible glee of the young men in the crowds, and the sadism they evinced, reminds us of the special power of the ignorant to impede the good. The pictures that television appropriately mostly did not show and the Internet inevitably mostly did were horrifying in a way that was reminiscent of the first still pictures of the Trade Center victims of 9/11. It was like seeing people in business suits falling through the air again. It was as if someone pointed a camera at evil and actually caught it in the act.

The Americans who were murdered were, according to the wires, working for a security company, a North Carolina-based subcontractor hired by the U.S. government, among other things, to guard convoys.

The convoys carried food. They carried it to Fallujah.

That is the bottom line right there. That is what makes us different from the terrorists. There is a part of me that would like to permanently erase that city from the map. The rest of me knows how wrong that would be.

It is not as if we lack the power. If the appropriate person gave such an order, the task would be complete within hours. A few planes would appear on the horizon and then the city would be gone. Our troops would never again be bothered by anything Fallujah had to offer...man, animal or the lice they once carried.

They, on the other hand, have little power. They can launch an occasional mortar at a hotel. Hide a bomb in the road. Burn a captured SUV. Kill the civilians within. Drag their bodies through the streets.

Some, even Americans, say that it is bad that we have power. That it is unfortunate that our enemies do not. The interesting thing about that position is that holding it changes nothing in the minds of our enemies. They still hate you. They would still kill you, if they could.

Some of the Iraqi people have been won over by our generosity. We liberated them from the tyranny of Saddam. We have rebuilt infrastructure. We have provided food and water.

It is not possible to win over the hearts of those who still hate us. Every act of kindness is rejected. Their view of us is concrete; permenant. We cannot quell their hate, so our only option is to remove their ability to act upon it. This recent act of terrorism in Fallujah must be countered.

If an unforgettable message is not sent to the young men of Fallujah, the young nihilists will be inspired, and the lesson of their nihilism--brutality trumps goodwill--will gain ground. The progressives of Iraq will be further disheartened, and all of those there from the West to help, from contract workers to military troops, will feel more beset, more resentful and less hopeful of a good outcome.

The terrible pictures of the charred bodies on the bridge cannot be erased, and no one who saw them is going to forget them. But they can in time come to be accompanied by other pictures--of determined U.S. Marines, for instance, rounding up the men who massed on the bridge under the bodies, and brandished their weapons, and laughed.

We cannot simply react. We should not overact. But we must act.
Categories
Archives
March 2010
S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      

Complete Archives

Tools
Search:
  Advanced Search

Mailing List:



Currently Reading
Recently Read
Animal Farm

Animal Farm
George Orwell

Life of Pi

Life of Pi
Yann Martel

The Fourth K

The Fourth K
Mario Puzo

Catch 22

Catch 22
Joseph Heller

the Sicilian

the Sicilian
Mario Puzo

The Quantum Rose

The Quantum Rose
Catherine Asaro

Members
Sponsors
Blogroll
Links
Stats
Entries: 2147
Comments: 2925
Trackbacks: 665
Members: 258

Most Recent:
  Entry: 11/09/08 9:38
  Comment: 11/17/08 12:27
  Visitor: 03/11/10 9:22

Powered by:
  ExpressionEngine

Extreme Tracking